No one who asks the question, “What’s your problem?” is expressing an invitation to join them in the quest for a solution. It is a statement costumed as a question. In linguistics, this sort of accusation-posing-as-question/concern is known by a linguistic term that I have not researched. “Accusation-posing-as-question,” or APAQ works for me, though.
It is aggressively passive-aggressive almost approximately one-hundred percent of the time that it is uttered. The person speaking the non-rhetorical non-question is profoundly certain of one thing, is philosophically sure of this: That they are not now doing, nor have they just been doing, nor were they about to do, something that falls in the range between perplexing to annoying to criminal.
It is a non-question that I have not yet in this life found it necessary to ask, not because I am an agreeable sort who causes no problems, but because I usually wait for someone who is having a problem with me and my doings to speak up (sometimes for too long—I can be aggressively passive-aggressive, too, sad to say). Also, I learned from childhood to read people, and that comes in handy.
Once upon a time, I was the sort of person who, if you stepped on my foot, I apologized for getting between you and the ground. This sort of warped, passive personality does not produce pleasant social situations if it does not eventually find its voice, because all of those annoying things that human beings do (slam doors, breathe loudly, cut in front of each other in lines, do things too quietly, pretend to be interested when they are not) get memorized and add up to one big annoyed individual. Thus, I used to be the person who was asked “What’s your problem?” a lot because my reactions to small annoyances would eventually come out and not be at all proportionate to the annoyance.
It is a non-question that I get non-asked less and less frequently now. But my eye-rolling self, the person who has been told he has “loud” facial expressions, he still believes that most of the habits of most human beings fall somewhere in the range between perplexing to annoying to criminal. He just writes about these things here before he loudly rolls his eyes.
* * * *
Please subscribe to The Gad About Town on Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/thegadabouttown
The WordPress Daily Prompt for March 1 asks, “What question do you hate to be asked? Why?”