Landing on a Rocky Rubber Duck

It took over a decade for the Rosetta space probe to travel approximately four billion miles. While not exactly a meander through the inner solar system—for several years it has been traveling at 34,000 miles per hour—its looping journey to Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko actually led it be misidentified once, seven years ago this week, when astronomers noticed a previously unidentified asteroid heading our way. It was even given an asteroid name, 2007 VN84, before it was correctly identified and everyone laughed uproariously.

In August, Rosetta arrived at Comet 67P/C-G, its destination for the entire trip. Three times, the probe’s path brought it close to its home planet, which provided a gravitational swing each time to throw it farther away from the inner solar system. In one complicated months-long maneuver, it swung out by Mars, took a boost from that encounter to return to Earth at a faster speed, and then passed Mars again; that solar system pick-and-roll flung it into the asteroid belt, the rock quarry orbiting between Mars and Jupiter. The European Space Agency has provided an interactive website to illustrate this: “Where is Rosetta?

The comet is as old as comets are, billions of years old; it is made of stuff left over from the formation of the solar system. Comet 67P is a comet stuck in a stable orbit around the sun; it does not venture far beyond Jupiter’s orbit and does not come much closer to the sun than inside Mars’ orbit. One orbit, one year on Comet 67P, is about six and a half years. Every three years it is as close as it will come to the sun and every three years it is as far away as its orbit takes it. Thus, for Rosetta and its lander, it offers no surprises but many discoveries.

Right now, the comet is in the asteroid belt and making its return to the inner solar system. For the first time, it has a hanger-on. Today, Comet 67P, the Rosetta space probe, and the Philae lander are traveling partners 310 million miles from Earth.

It is the ideal comet to attempt to land on. Other comets, with longer orbits, like Halley’s Comet and other Oort cloud objects, develop a long tail as they come close to the sun, heat up, melt a little, and throw off material. They become unstable. This was spectacularly seen one year ago, when Comet ISON disintegrated as it approached the sun. Comet 67P has been through this process countless times already and is probably not going to heat up and eject too much material, but if it does, science will have a close-up seat.

In September, it started to heat up and gave Rosetta some spectacular views:

comet 67p

Jets springing from Comet 67P

Right now, comet and company are traveling at over 40,000 miles per hour, or 18 kilometers per second. As remarkable as that is, the manipulations and maneuvers to land Philae on the surface—which is dusty and icy and rocky and there is no way to know how stable that surface is or how thick the dust is without getting close and risking everything in a one-and-done landing attempt—slowed the lander to a one-meter-per-second speed after dropping it off. So the lander was traveling 40,000 miles per hour with the comet, and one meter per second closer to the comet, and the landing was not smooth: It bounced, but not off the comet entirely. Harpoons were supposed to secure it, but they did not fire for reasons still unknown. A few footpad screws appear to have been enough to settle the lander in place; millions of miles of travel and it was just like building a desk from Ikea: the big bolts that you were sure you weren’t going to use were never needed in the first place.

As Rosetta approached the comet earlier this year, it became apparent that the object had a complicated shape, that it has one big section and one smaller section. It is shaped like a rubber duck, and my affection for ducks is well-known. The lander is on the comet’s head, which is the smaller part, only about a mile and a half by a mile and a half.

This may be the most amazing fact of the whole project: the comet is not the size of a planet or even an asteroid; it is tiny. There is no human-sized comparison one can make to this without sounding ridiculous. It is like shooting a paperclip at a taxiing 747 and hitting an open window and landing it in a seat in first class. Or: Imagine you are driving cross-country at top speed tomorrow morning. Let’s say you are in Texas and the road is wide-open; it is like the world belongs to you. You hear your cellphone ring, try to locate it, find it but bobble it awkwardly in your hands; you accidentally bounce it out your open window, and then learn that it landed in someone’s hands while they were on top of the Eiffel Tower. Sounds silly, but it does not come close to matching the feat that the European Space Agency successfully accomplished today.

And now comes the science-y part.

The WordPress Daily Prompt for November 12 asks, “Today you can write about anything, in whatever genre or form, but your post must include a speeding car, a phone call, and a crisp, bright morning. (Wildcard: you can swap any of the above for a good joke.)”

* * * *
Please subscribe to The Gad About Town on Facebook:


  1. MelissaM · November 12, 2014

    Your posts are always interesting.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Kmandu · November 13, 2014

      I hate to bring this to your attention, but did you know that your head is on up-side-down?

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Kmandu · November 12, 2014

    I’m not sure if it was a the title involving a Rocky Rubber Duck or the picture that got my attention first. I love reading about things that should be impossible but they’re not. Thanks for sharing this tale so lay person can understand it. I think we all find ourselves hoping for the impossible to happen sometime in our lives… now we know that maybe it’s not such a ridiculous idea.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. lifelessons · November 13, 2014

    I can’t get over your interest in and knowledge of such a wide range of topics. You make everything interesting and more easily understood. Your illustrations and explanations bring this piece to life. Thanks for making this outstanding achievement come to life for us. Judy

    Liked by 1 person

  4. dcrelief · November 13, 2014

    WordPress Prompt play:

    Oh phone, phone – must you ring?
    Is this call an important thing?
    The tones you play on such such crisp morn
    invoke that speeding car to sound it’s horn.

    Why? Because my foot considers brakin’
    as driving becomes a skill forsaken.
    My coordination takes a back seat
    or maybe you – the seat should meet!

    Toss it now!! Be safe.

    Mark, I enjoyed the post. I find it amazing what man can do – such great exploratory endeavors. For now at least it is still peaceful in space.

    The video of the Rosetta’s path was remarkable – I watched until it completely disappeared far left of screen and reappeared some time later on far right… like a giant game of dodge ball!

    Sweet story of the “duck about town,” I wondered what that tiny spot of green-gold was about. Your health issue, associated with the post sounds distressing. I can understand on some levels – having a few things to deal with on my own. Still you’re a heads up person and the spirit is encouraging to many, like me. Thank you for sharing a part of your life in such a positive atmosphere!

    Forgive the long comment – but I wanted to acknowledge the work you have here, included in this post with links. Have a great week.

    Most sincerely,
    Dixie Copeland

    Liked by 2 people

  5. Swoosieque · November 16, 2014

    I have been intrigued with this since it’s been in the news recently, but, your explanation of how unbelievable the landing is, is incredible and THAT is what is more intriguing to me than anything – the science/engineering of being able to land on that speeding rock! ” It is like shooting a paperclip at a taxiing 747 and hitting an open window and landing it in a seat in first class.”

    Great post! 😀

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Pingback: Acrostic Poem / Poetry – “Left Logically Yet Rightly Creative” | toofulltowrite (I've started so I'll finish)
  7. Mark Aldrich · June 14, 2015

    Reblogged this on The Gad About Town and commented:

    Big news from the Rosetta mission, written about here in November: the Philae lander woke up today! The lander had bounced when it arrived on the surface of the comet and wound up somewhere in shadows, where it could not get sunlight to keep its batteries charged. Within days of landing, it went into hibernation mode with the mission team still not certain where exactly the lander had planted itself. Seven months of silence until today.

    The comet, which is making its way towards the inner solar system and the sun, turned in the right direction, or more likely, heat from the sun melted whatever icy ridge was shielding the lander, and then sunlight found the lander’s solar panels, and the batteries recharged. The lander, which is a computer about the size of a refrigerator, rebooted and began sending messages to the orbiter, which has continued doing its job of photographing the comet. Philae sent information today that it had stored seven months ago in its last few moments awake, when it detected that it did not have enough power to send but could at least save the data, just in case it ever “woke up” again. Almost gets me in the feels.

    The temperature on comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko is very cold, but the lander’s operating temperature was reported as optimal: -35ºC. (Same as my heart.) Whatever’s optimal, it is working again.

    An article:


  8. SD Gates · June 14, 2015

    Very interesting post. Love the analogies!!!!


Please comment here. Thank you, Mark.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.